Additionally style of peculiar that from 50+ reactions saying creepy while draw the practically alone saying do it now as better. Precisely why even bother asking? posted by Kellydamnit at 3:36 PM on

We talked they more than with a few buddies of my own and that I’m contemplating providing it to some other woman i’m not sure well whatsoever. She is wrestling with some self-esteem issues, from the things I’ve heard, and might do with only the theory that somebody believes she’s unique

Gaaaaaaah. If you want to create anyone pleased by providing all of them a banjo, get a hold of an individual who wants a banjo and present they in their mind. This plan you must provide some girl, a lady, a banjo is more about yourself plus ideas on relationship than it is about all of them, this is exactly why it really is very weird. Could you supply the banjo to a beneficial male friend? No? Didn’t think-so. published by ThePinkSuperhero at 3:41 PM on [42 favorites]

It appears thus fetishistic

This arbitrary cheering up ladies with self-confidence problems by providing them banjos they can’t perform is really standard 4 about Gein-ometer of creepiness.

Tune in to just what 50+ folk on listed here are suggesting. uploaded by fire&wings at 3:42 PM on [2 preferences]

wow – so many comments here about creepy it could be, and also you best answer the one which will abide by you? why also publish issue if you are going to ignore the overwhelming majority of the solutions?

it’s really weird. I would become most weirded off to bring an anonymous banjo provide. It is very totally possible that she will understand it ended up being you just who delivered it – regardless of if doesn’t have your own identity on it anyplace, she will realize you are the sort of individual take action like this, and it surely will completely changes her perception people for the even worse. don’t take action. Salzburg bride for marriage submitted by 5_13_23_42_69_666 at 3:45 PM on [1 favored]

We discussed they more than which includes pals of mine and I’m contemplating providing it to a different girl i don’t know really whatsoever. She actually is wrestling with a few self-confidence dilemmas, from what I’ve read, and may manage with only the idea that somebody believes she is unique. The thing that makes this unlike that metafilter thread (I can’t keep in mind which) where that female ended up being stating she got flowers anonymously for annually, and missed aside for many years that it was the lady companion? I would exactly like that it is a mystery, a pleasurable secret, a grand motion. Yeah, possibly this is a tiny bit self-centered, I’d feel absurd to think otherwise, it is here no good result right here?

That you are thus hung-up on providing a banjo to a lady implies that you’re achieving this with objectification in mind. This can be about your own fantasy of a hot chick playing a banjo under a tree, rather than nothing about these people as actual people–which is a huge section of what makes it look both weird and self-centered, as well.

(And truthfully? It is shudder-worthy adequate to create me personally cringe within notion of picking up my own personal banjo facing unusual men. )

I do not consider you will be listening to individuals contained in this thread

Additionally talking as a terrible banjo-player, it really is an extremely tough string instrument to relax and play even if you are curious about they. I believe more than virtually any different device, absolutely increased chance that this will simply end up being an expensive paperweight, accumulating dust in a corner. Though I would personally getting slightly skeeved out about receiving private roses for a year, no less than there the content is obvious plus it doesn’t warrant a ton of run the an element of the receiver to be valued. submitted by PhoBWanKenobi at 3:47 PM on [14 favorites]